A loitering munition (LM) is a type of self-destructive unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) equipped with a warhead that is typically designed to loiter until a target is designated, then crash into it. Common terms like suicide drone, kamikaze drone,[ ] or exploding drone are used to indicate both of the loitering munition and the one-way attack drone. They enable attacks against hidden targets that emerge for short periods without placing high-value weapons platform near the target area. Unlike many other types of munitions, their attacks can be changed mid-mission or aborted. Loitering munitions are typically aerial platforms, but include some autonomous undersea vehicles with similar characteristics.
Loitering weapons emerged in the 1980s for the suppression of enemy air defenses (SEAD) role, and were deployed for SEAD by some military forces in the 1990s. In the 2000s, they were developed for additional roles, from long-range strikes and fire support to short-range tactical systems that fit in a backpack.
History
First development and terminology
AGM-136 Tacit Rainbow on display at the National Museum of the U.S. Air Force in Dayton, Ohio]]Initially, loitering munitions were not referred to as such but rather as "suicide UAVs" or "loitering missiles". Different sources point at different projects as originating the weapon category. The failed US AGM-136 Tacit Rainbow program
[ An Introduction to Autonomy in Weapon Systems, pages 13–14, By: Paul Scharre and Michael C. Horowitz, CNAS Working paper, Feb 2015] or the 1980s initial Israeli Delilah variants
[ Loitering Weapons are making a Comeback, Defense Update, June 2009] are mentioned by some sources.
[ Drone Strike!: UCAVs and Aerial Warfare in the 21st Century, By Bill Yenne, , pages 106–107] The Iranian
HESA Ababil was produced in the 1980s but its exact production date is unknown.
The Israeli
IAI Harpy was produced in the late 1980s.
Early projects did not use the "loitering munition" nomenclature, which emerged much later; they used terminology existing at the time. For instance the AGM-136 Tacit Rainbow was described in a 1988 article:
Initial role in suppression of enemy air defense
In response to the first generation of fixed-installation surface-to-air missiles (SAMs) such as S-75 and S-125, the U.S. military developed SEAD doctrine and
Wild Weasel weapons, including anti-radiation missiles (ARMs) such as AGM-45 Shrike. The
Soviet countered with mobile SAMs such as 2K12 Kub and intermittent use of
radar.
In Israel's 1982 Operation Mole Cricket 19,
and air-launched Samson decoys were used over suspected SAM areas to saturate enemy SAMs and to bait them to activate their radar systems, which were then attacked by ARMs.
[ Six Days in June (Hebrew), IAF bulletin, issue 145, June 2002][ Surface to Air Missile Effectiveness in Past Conflicts, Technical Report APA-TR-2010-1001, Dr Carlo Kopp, AFAIAA, SMIEEE, PEng, October 2010]
In the 1980s, programs such as the IAI Harpy and AGM-136 Tacit Rainbow integrated anti-radiation sensors into a drone or missile coupled with command and control and loitering capabilities. This allowed the attacking force to put relatively cheap munitions over suspected SAM sites, then attack when the SAM battery was spotted.[ Meet Israel's 'Suicide Squad' of Self-Sacrificing Drones, August 2016, The Drive][ ADAPTIVE DISCRETE EVENT SIMULATION FOR ANALYSIS OF HARPY SWARM ATTACK, Brandon J. Cobb, Naval Postgraduate School, Thesis, September 2011][ Loitering, Smart Cruise Missile Marketed to U.S. Navy , National Defense, June 2001]
Evolution into additional roles
Starting in the 2000s, loitering weapons have been developed for additional roles from relatively long-range strikes and fire support
[ British Army Sets to Deploy Fire Shadow Loitering Weapons to Afghanistan by Early 2012 Defense Update, September 2011] to tactical, very-short-range tactical use.
[ Military Investigates Killer Drones That Can Fit in Rucksacks National Defense, July 2011][ A Tiny Missile That Waits Overhead—Silent, Patient and Deadly, WarIsBoring, January 2014][ AeroVironment producing Switchblade missiles for Army UPI, October 2016][ Loitering Autonomous Weapons , Defense Update, January 2007] In the 2016 Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, an
IAI Harop was used against a bus used as a troop transport for Armenian soldiers.
[ Israeli-made kamikaze drone spotted in Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, Washington Post, April 2016] The
ZALA Lancet and several
Shahed drones, including the HESA Shahed 136, have been used by
Russia in the Russo-Ukrainian war, while Ukraine has fielded loitering munitions such as the UJ-25 Skyline and the American-made AeroVironment Switchblade, which is deployed to
and fits in a backpack.
During conflicts in the 2010s and 2020s, conventional armies and non-state militants began modifying common commercial Drone racing into "FPV loitering munitions" by the attachment of a small explosive, so-named because of the first-person view (FPV) they provide the operator. Explosive ordnance such as an IED, grenade, mortar round or an RPG warhead are fitted to an FPV drone then deployed to aerial bomb tactical targets. FPV drones also allow direct reconnaissance during the drone's strike mission.
Since the start of the Russo-Ukrainian war in 2022, both Russian and Ukrainian forces were producing thousands of FPV drones every month by October 2023, many of which were donated by volunteer groups. Escadrone Pegasus and the Vyriy Drone Molfar are two examples of the low-cost drones that rapidly evolved in 2022–23 during the war. In 2022, the UK Government announced it was providing "hundreds of loitering munitions" to Ukraine. On 9 November 2023, Ukrainian soldiers claimed to have used a civilian-donated FPV drone to destroy a Russian Tor missile system on the Kupiansk front, showcasing the potential cost-effectiveness of fielding such munitions. A Tor missile system costs some $24 million to build, which could buy 14,000 FPV drones.
Characteristics
Loitering munitions may be as simple as an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) with attached explosives that is sent on a potential
kamikaze mission, and may even be constructed with commercially available
with strapped-on explosives.
[ ISIS Using Kamikaze Drones in Iraq, Popular Mechanics, October 2016]
Purpose-built munitions are more elaborate in flight and control capabilities, warhead size and design, and onboard sensors for locating targets.[ iClean – Loitering Attack UCAV, Artzi Dror, Technion Institute of Technology, 2012] Some loitering munitions use a human operator to locate targets whereas others, such as IAI Harop, can function autonomously searching and launching attacks without human intervention.[ Israel Unveils Loitering Anti-Missile Drone , Defense Update, 2009][ Harpy Air Defense Suppression System , Defense Update, 2006] Another example is UVision Air HERO solutions – the loitering systems are operated remotely, controlled in real time by a communications system and equipped with an electro-optical camera whose images are received by the command and control station.
Some loitering munitions may return and be recovered by the operator if they are unused in an attack and have enough fuel; in particular this is characteristic of UAVs with a secondary explosive capability.[ IAI's ROTEM – Tactical Multirotor Killer Drone, Defense Update, 2016] Other systems, such as the Delilah[ The Secrets of Delilah (Hebrew), IAF bulletin, issue 184, December 2008][ Delilah – The IAF Loitering Missile, Defense Update, June 2009] do not have a recovery option and are self-destructed in mission aborts.
Countermeasures
Russia uses
ZALA Lancet drones in Ukraine. Since spring 2022 Ukrainian forces have been
Anti-drone mesh around their artillery pieces using chain link fencing, wire mesh and even wooden logs as part of the construction. One analyst told Radio Liberty that such cages were "mainly intended to disrupt Russian Lancet munitions." A picture supposedly taken from January 2023 shows the rear half of a Lancet drone that failed to detonate due to such cages. Likewise Ukrainian forces have used inflatable decoys and wooden vehicles, such as
HIMARS, to confuse and deceive Lancet drones.
Ukrainian soldiers report shooting down Russian drones with . Russian soldiers use electronic warfare to disable or misdirect Ukrainian drones and have reportedly used the Stupor anti-drone rifle, which uses an electromagnetic pulse that disrupts a drone's GPS navigation. A Royal United Services Institute study in 2022 found that Russian Electronic Warfare units, in March and April 2022, knocked out or shot down 90% of Ukrainian drones that they had at the start of the war in February 2022. The main success was in jamming GPS and radio links to the drones.
Both Ukraine and Russia rely on electronic warfare to defeat FPV drones. Such jammers are now used on Ukrainian trenches and vehicles. Russian forces have built jammers that can fit into a backpack. Pocket-size jammers for soldiers were also developed. As of June 2023 Ukraine was losing 5-10,000 drones a month, or 160 per day, according to
Ukrainian soldiers.
This has led to Russia creating wire guided FPV drones, similar to a wire-guided missile or even wire-guided torpedoes. Those drones typically have fibre optic cables 5–20 km in length. Such guidance makes the link between operators and FPV drone immune to jamming. It also allows for much faster and better quality updates from the drone, even from locations where radio contact would be poor, and doesn't reveal operator's or drone's location by radio signals. They also need less power to communicate, and so can be used to idle on the ground for ambushes. They have reduced range, payload and manoeuvrability compared to wireless drones, although in practice, range and agility of the wired drones can be even higher than those of the radio-controlled ones, given their reduced control latency and increased survivability. Ukraine has also responded by using autonomous drones tasking to ensure that a jammed drone can hit a target. In March 2024 footage put on social media showed a Ukrainian FPV drone being jammed just before it struck a target. Despite the loss of operator control it still managed to strike the target.
Russian tanks have been fitted with rooftop slat armor at the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine which could provide protection against loitering munitions in some circumstances. Some Ukrainian tanks taking part in the 2023 Ukrainian counteroffensive were also spotted using roof screens.
On 21 March 2024, recent footage of the submarine Tula showed that it has been fitted with a slat armor to prevent drone strikes, the first ocean-going asset to carry such a modification.
Comparison to similar weapons
Loitering munitions fit in the niche between
and unmanned combat aerial vehicles (UCAVs).
The following table compares similar size-class cruise missiles, loitering munitions, and UCAVS:
Whereas some cruise missiles, such as the Block IV Tomahawk, have the ability to loiter and have some sensory and remote control features,
[Kris Osborn, 18 May 2016, The U.S. Navy Has Big Plans for the Lethal Tomahawk Missile, The National Interest.] their primary mission is typically strike and not target acquisition. Cruise missiles, as their name implies, are optimized for long-range flight at constant speed both in terms of propulsion systems and
wings or
lifting body design. They are often unable to loiter at slow fuel-efficient speeds which significantly reduces potential loiter time even when the missile has some loiter capabilities.
[Takahashi, Timothy, et al. "A multi-disciplinary survey of advanced subsonic tactical cruise missile configurations." 43rd AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit. 2005.]
Conversely almost any UAV could be piloted to crash onto a target and most could be fitted with an improvised explosive warhead. However the primary use of a UAV or UCAV would be for recoverable flight operations carrying reconnaissance equipment and/or munitions. While many UAVs are explicitly designed with loitering in mind, they are not optimized for a diving attack, often lacking forward facing cameras, lacking in control response-speed which is unneeded in regular UAV flight, and are noisy when diving, potentially providing warning to the target. UAV's, being designed as multi-use platforms, often have a unit cost that is not appropriate for regular one-time expendable mission use.
The primary mission of a loitering munition is reaching the suspected target area, target acquisition during a loitering phase, followed by a self-destructive strike, and the munition is optimized in this regard in terms of characteristics (e.g. very short engine lifetime, silence in strike phase, speed of strike dive, optimization toward loitering time instead of range/speed) and unit cost (appropriate for a one-off strike mission).
Ethical and international humanitarian law concerns
Loitering munitions that can make
Autonomous robot attack decisions (man out of the loop) raise moral, ethical, and international humanitarian law concerns because a human being is not involved in the decision to attack and potentially kill humans. A distinction is often drawn with
fire-and-forget missiles in common use since the 1960s, which may lock-on after launch or be sensor-fuzed, but whose flight time is typically limited and a human launches them at an area where enemy activity is strongly suspected. An autonomous loitering munition, on the other hand, may be launched at an area where enemy activity is only probable, and loiter searching autonomously for targets for hours after the initial launch decision, though it may be able to request final authorization for an attack from a human. The IAI Harpy and IAI Harop are frequently cited as aerial systems that set a precedent in this way—though some note that
also loiter and may kill indiscriminately.
[Garcia, Denise. "Killer robots: Why the US should lead the ban." Global Policy 6.1 (2015): 57–63.][Sharkey, Noel. "Saying 'no!' to lethal autonomous targeting." Journal of Military Ethics 9.4 (2010): 369–383.][Alston, Philip. "Lethal robotic technologies: the implications for human rights and international humanitarian law." JL Inf. & Sci. 21 (2011): 35.]
Users and producers
, loitering munitions are used by the armed forces of several countries, including:
-
– YIHA-III
-
– HERO 30, HERO 120
-
– HRESH, BEEB 1800,
AW21[ EDEX 2023 witnesses AirWorker's AW21 loitering munition presentation . Air Recognition. 5 December 2023.]
-
– Drone 40,
[ A drone with a can-doom attitude. C4ISRNET. 5 June 2019.] Innovaero OWL
-
– IAI Harpy, IAI Harop,
SkyStriker, STM Kargu, Qirği, Quzgün
-
– UBAK-25 Chekan
, Berkut-BM
-
– Anshar
[ Brazilian firm Mac Jee unveils exploding drone, with demo in months. Defense News. 17 November 2023.]
-
– IAI Harpy, CH-901, WS-43, ASN-301
[ DSA 2016: China details CH-901 UAV and loitering munition, Jane’s, April 2016][ Idex 2017: Catic reveals details about Harpy-type loitering munition, Jane’s, March 2017]
-
- Switchblade, Colibri, Larinae
-
- Delta-WB Warmate
[ WB GROUP unmanned systems for Georgia. WB Group. 18 May 2022.][ Defense Forces of Georgia Received UAVs Produced in Georgia and American Radars. Ministry of Defence of Georgia. 14 December 2023.]
-
– Attalus,
[ DEFEA 2023 – Attalus, a Greek Loitering Munition from Intracom Defense. European Defence Review. 12 May 2023.] Aihmi AHM-1X[ EDEX 2023: Greek company SAS Technology displays Aihmi AHM-1X 70mm loitering munition . Air Recognition. 6 December 2023.]
-
– Rajata,
BETA UAS
-
– Nagastra-1,
IAI Harpy, IAI Harop,[ Harop Loitering Munitions System for the IAF, India Defence Review, January 2014] SkyStriker, Warmate, Trinetra, ALS-50, Johnnette JM-1.[ Johnnette JM-1] Shaurya-1, Kadet[ Kadet] Loitering Aerial Munition, Overwatch PHOLOS, Zulu DRAP, Sureshastra Mk1, UVision Air, Berkut-BM
-
– HESA Ababil, Meraj-521,
[ US Switchblade Drone ‘Knock Off’ Meraj-521 Unveiled By Iran; Comes After Grand Success Of Its UAVs In Ukraine. EurAsian Times. 21 October 2022.] Shahin-1, Zhubin and possibly others[ Iran's navy touts 'suicide drone', USA Today, October 2016][ Iran Tests 'Kamikaze' Suicide Drone, The National Interest Papers Offer a Peek at ISIS' Drones, Lethal and Largely Off-the-Shelf, New York Times, January 2017][ Portable Attack Drones or Loitering Munitions, SPS Landforces, September 2016]
-
– IAI Harpy, IAI Harop, IAI Harpy NG, IAI Green Dragon, IAI Rotem L, Orbiter 1K,
[ Aeronautics introduces Orbiter 1K loitering munition, Flight Global, May 2015] Delilah, SkyStriker,[ Elbit announces new SkyStriker loitering munition, Jane's Defence Weekly, September 2016] Spike Firefly, HERO loitering munitions series,[ Israeli companies pitching loitering munitions for US Army programme, FlightGlobal, April 2016] Viper, Lanius,[ AI-driven combat drone can search buildings and execute suicide attacks. New Atlas. 20 November 2022.] Point Blank,[ Israel Aerospace Industries unveils Point Blank – a hand-launched electro-optical guided missile. European Defence Review. 19 January 2023.] SpyX,[ PARIS AIR SHOW NEWS: New Loitering Munition Promises to Go the Distance. National Defense Magazine. 20 June 2023.] and upgraded variants.[ Vietnam Eyes Israel's Delilah Standoff Missile, and F-16s Could Be Next, The Warzone, March 2017]
-
– Switchblade
-
– IAI Harop, IAI Harpy, SpyX
-
– GIDS Sarkash, E-RAD, Rover LM, Xpear MX-150, NASTP Dark Angel Series, YIHA-III, GIDS Blaze series, NASTP KaGeM V3
-
– WB Electronics Warmate
[ Warmate expendable UAV in production for two customers, Flight Global, April 2016]
-
– UAVision
-
– ZALA Kub-BLA ("Cube"), ZALA Lancet,
[ Под крышей дрона: ВМФ усиливается БПЛА-камикадзе, Izvestia, 20 October 2021][ Russian Naval Ships to Be Armed With Kamikaze Drones, The Defense Post, 2 November 2021] Ushkuynik KVN, Gerbera, BM-35, Molniya.
-
– Gavran 145,
[ Serbia may become biggest operator of military drones in Balkans. Defense News. 21 November 2022.] Osica, Komarac, Vila 1
-
– IAI Harop
-
– AX-2 Predator
-
– Paramount N-Raven
-
– Devil Killer,
[ South Korea's Kamikaze UAV Could Scare the Ojom Out of Kim Jong-un , Gizmodo, October 2012][ South Korea developing 'kamikaze' attack drone, Fox News, October 2012] IAI Harpy
-
- Q-SLAM-40
-
– Kamin-25
-
- Shaheen
-
– NCSIST Chien Hsiang,
NCSIST Fire Cardinal
-
- Robit AZAB,
IAI Harpy,[ IAI Gets $100 Million Contract for HAROP Killer Drones , Defense Update, 2009] STM Kargu, STM Alpagu, Transvaro-Havelsan Fedai, LENTATEK Kargı, Roketsan-STM Alpagut[ Turkish firms unveil a new loitering munition. Defense News. 28 October 2022.]
-
– SkyStriker
-
– QX-1,
[ Edge Group unveils kamikaze drones at Idex. Defense News. 22 February 2021.] Hunter SP,[ Hunter SP. EDGE Group.] Hunter 2-S,[ UAE Shows Off A Compact Box Launcher Concept Full Of 21 AI-Enabled Swarming Suicide Drones. The Drive/The War Zone. 21 February 2022.][ Following first demonstration, Edge unveils swarming drones based on AI technology. Defense News. 22 February 2022.] Hunter 5, Hunter 10, Shadow 25, Shadow 50,[ As UAV tech spreads, Gulf firms bet on upgrades with drone-to-satellite links. Breaking Defense. 3 June 2022.] RW-24, N-Raven
-
– Switchblade, Overwatch PHOLOS
-
– ALTIUS-600M, AeroVironment Switchblade, Phoenix Ghost, Raytheon Coyote,
[ Surface Navy 2017: Coyote earmarked for ISR and offensive roles, Jane’s, January 2017] UVision Air, Point Blank, Northrop Grumman Lumberjack
-
– , AQ-400 Scythe, Bober, Liutyi,
Overwatch PHOLOS, Phoenix Ghost, QinetiQ Banshee, RAM II, ST-35 Silent Thunder, Switchblade, UJ-25 Skyline, Warmate, FP-1, FP-2, Chaklun-K, Morok, Palianytsia, Sting (anti-drone loitering munition), Tupolev Tu-141, Tupolev Tu-143, Sypaq Corvo (conversion)
-
– (Houthis) – Qasef-1/2K,
[ Suicide Drones Have Migrated to The Conflict in Yemen, The Warzone, March 2017] Shahed 131, Shahed 136, Samad-2/3, Shahed-101
North Korea
In March 2025,
state media said leader Kim Jong Un oversaw testing of AI-equipped reconnaissance and suicide drones produced by the country's Unmanned Aerial Technology Complex, inspected a new reconnaissance drone and an early warning and control (AEW) aircraft, and pushed to expand the production of unmanned systems, citing their importance in modern warfare.
See also
-
Boeing Persistent Munition Technology Demonstrator
-
Copperhead (UUV), a family of autonomous unmanned undersea vehicles with loitering munitions capability.
-
Flying bomb
-
Low Cost Autonomous Attack System
-
Sypaq Corvo Precision Payload Delivery System
-
Television guidance
-
V-1 flying bomb
-
XM501 Non-Line-of-Sight Launch System
Notes
Further reading
External links